Plans for a five-storey block of flats branded a “monstrosity” in the centre of Spalding have been thrown out.
Cley Developments Ltd’s proposals for 12 flats and downstairs retail space on the corner of Station Road and Sheep Market had been recommended for approval by planning officers.
However councillors on South Holland District Council’s Planning Committee felt the building was too big and would have a detrimental effect on nearby properties many of which are at least Grade II listed, including the former magistrates court.
Speaking on behalf of the applicant Craig Smith of Robert Doughty Consultancy Limited, told the meeting: “Our scheme will see the redevelopment of a town centre site which is an area of waste ground occupied by a redundant shelter.”
He described it as a “bold and contemporary building that will enhance the character of the conservation area and wider context.”
However Coun Christine Lawton called it a “prison” and said: “This is from the architectural school called putting a quart in a pint pot. It’s only matched in hideousness by the BT building that’s near it.
“This is a conservation area, the Sessions House is around the corner and the whole area needs lifting up, not blighting by this monstrosity.”
Coun Peter Coupland called the building “hideous” and said: “I don’t think Spalding’s ready for five-storey buildings yet, if ever.”
The design did find favour with some councillors with Coun Avery saying: “I think this part of Spalding is hideous and this goes along way to improving that situation.”
Councillors initially against granting permission then voted 9-6 to refuse the application with the committee chair Roger Gambba-Jones saying he felt it was “a storey too high”. He said: “I’m bemused by the fact anybody is building retail when we’re hearing the High Street is in the toilet.
“There’s no shortage of empty properties.”
